Dr Stephen H Allnutt
M.B.Ch., B, FRCPC, FRANZCP
Forensic Psychiatry
Level 5, Suite 506, 75 Miller Street, North Sydney NSW 2060
PO Box 876, North Sydney NSW 2059
Telephone: 61 2 9929 2913 Facsmilie: 61 2 99292914
10 April 2012
CONFIDENTIAL
Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions
Reserve Bank Building
GPO Box 595
CANBERRA CITY ACT 2601
Attention: Ms Sian Jowitt
Telephone: 61 6207 5399
Facsimile: 61 6207 5428
Dear Ms Jowit
RE: ALEXANDER MARCEL ANDRE SEBASTIAN BARKER BAILIFF
DOB: 5:54PM TUESDAY 25TH AUGUST 1970 1 hour and 57 minutes before GOUGH WHITLAM's THREAT TO BLOCK SUPPLY
Your Reference: 201210593
Introduction
Thank you for your letter dated 25 January 2012.
You requested that I provide you with a psychiatric report in relation to the accussed, Alexander Marcel Andre Sebastian Barker Bailiff. This report represents a clinical evaluation conducted with the accussed at the AMC on 10 March 2012 and a telephone call on 27 March 2012. The purpose of this report is to provide an opinion with regard to his mental state at the material time of the alleged ofending.
He has been charged with a number of offences including minor theft for alleged offence that occurred on 27 November 2008, and between April 2011 and December 2011; improper use of an emergency call service for alleged offence, give false alarm of fire and emergency to other for alleged offence, contravene a protection violence order for alleged offence, trespass on premises for alleged offences.
I have previously provided a report dated 27 March 2012; this report corrects typing errors in that report.
Role Confidentiality and Consent
From the outset I explained to the accused that I was a psychiatrist requested by you to provide you with a psychiatric report in relation to his mental state. I explained to him that any information provided to me would not be confidential and could be made available to a wider public should it be tendered to Court. I formed the view that he understood this and consented to continue.
Provider No. 23951661 ABN 67 934 406 282
Alexander Marcel Andre Sebastian Barker Bailiff 10 April 2012
Source of Information
I have read the Expert Witness Code of Conduct Part 28 Rule 9C and Part 28A, Rule 2 of the District Court Rules and agree to be bound by those Codes.
I had the opportunity to review:
1. Police Statement of facts.
2. The criminal history.
3, The relevant law section.
4. A number of communications it appears provided to me by you, which are written by the accused.
He was 41 at the time that I saw him he was incarcerated at the AMC; he was not seeing a psychiatrist or a psychologist regularly; he was single; he was not taking medication.
Clinical Issues
From outset it should be stated that the accused's presentation was unusual; he was wearing glasses, a hat, his effect was intense; he manifested pressured and rapid speech, he was difficult to interrupt and urgent need to speak to me about Angela Magnocavallo and from outset explained that he had previously been in a motor vehicle accident; he was overfamiliar, and perservated (returning to the same topic repeatedly) and disinhibited.
He commenced by telling me that his solicitor Bernard Collaery was involved with his girlfriend, that Bernard Collaery had been a friend for 20 years and that he was having intercourse with his girlfriend Angela Magnocavallo; he was distressed by this because Bernard Collaery was his solicitor and that having intercourse with his girlfriend was unprofessional; Bernard Collaery had been his neighbour for 20 years; he felt it upsetting that his confident Angela Magnocavallo told him she was having a relationship with his solicitor.
On one occasion Bernard Collaery came into his driveway and told him that he should punch him and that on a second occasion Bernard Collaery came and told him that Angela Magnocavallo loved him; Bernard Collaery was still involved in his case; he kept having Bernard Collaery involved because he was involved before Bernard Collaery had intercourse with his girlfriend, who had slept in his house for 9 months.
He explained that the closest person in his life, Vanessa Bayliss (his sister), was killed when he was 15 years, 108 days and 12 hours old in a motor vehicle accident, it was very upsetting for him; he was in a coma he said after this for about four weeks with loss of consciousness for four weeks and broke his arm; he stated he was "15 years, 108 days and 12 hours" at the time that it happened.
He then again returned to the issue of how upset he was about the relationship that his confident Angela Magnocavallo was having with Bernard Collaery; at this stage I noted that he appeared to me to be quite perserverative on this issue.
He then went onto state that following the accident, he had been told that he suffered "elevation of mood, reduced concentration span, overtalkativeness, expanisiveness, overfamiliarity and euphoria"; he referred me to a book on brain damage brought out by Blackwell Press and Lishman referring particularly to page 127.
"Parker QC, Roger, Barrister-at-Law, (61 2 9221 3890), p.127, Chapter 7, Adducing Evidence to Prove or Disprove Brain Damage, Brian Damage Medico-Legal Aspects, Blackwell Press, Sydney, (1994). (My Phaedra complex Philip W. Bates is General Editor, Adjunct Professor, University of Sydney & Sir Owen Dixon Chambers)
"6. The Clinical Picture in Focal Cerebral Disorder Lishman says at p.16 that strictly focal brain damage can be responsible for both acute and chronic organic reactions. He says that a frontal lesion may confer distinctive changes of disposition and temperement. Most characteristic is a disinhibition with expanisive overfamiliarity, tactlessness, overtalk[at]iveness, childish excitement or prankish and punning social and ethical control may be diminished with lack of concern for the future and for the consequence of actions. Sexual indiscretions and petty misdemeanours may occur, or gross errors of judgement with regard to financial or interpersonal matters. Sometimes there is a marked indifference, even callousness for the feelings of others. Equally lack of anxiety and insight on the part of the patient into his or her condition. Elevation of mood is often seen, namely and empty and fatous euphoria rather than a true elation which communicates to the observer. In other cases the principal changes are lack of initiative, aspontaneity and a profound slowing of psychomotor activity. Concentration, attention and ability to carry out a planned activity are impaired by thee changes but performances on test of formal intelligence is often surprisingly well preserved once the patients has been secured.
Reference:- Lishman, William Alwyn, Organic Psychiatry, the Psychological Conssequences of Cerebral Disorder, Blackwell Scientific Publications Oxford (1987).
He went onto speak about Chief Justice Higgins and then went onto speak about issues surrounding World Health Organisation and what sounded to me like diagnosis criteria for International Classification for Impairment Disability Handicap.
Alexander Marcel Andre Sebastian Barker Bailiff 10 April 2012
In an attempt to keep him focused I enquired about his mental state, he said at the time that I saw him, his mood was normal, he denied euphoria or depression; he thought his concentration was "good" and then went onto tell me that he read the Bible in 14 days from New Years Day and the 14 January 2012 and between 27 December 2011 and 31 December 2011; that he had also read 700 pages of a book about what the Bible explains; he said when he read, all he has to do was be away from distractions and he could focus on his reading; he had high energy levels, by way of example he explained to me that he had ridden his bike from "Canberra to Queanbeyan to Captains Flat to Major's Creek to the Araluen Valley and then to Moruya Heads"; he had got Nelson's Mandela's book "Road to Freedom" and read it on Friday night, Saturday and Sunday and then returned to Canberra by bike, covering a distance of about 452 kilometres.
He then refered back to Bernard Cumacille and Gerrard Cumacille which he said was [Bernard Collaery and] Mel Gibson's actual name and the he asked me if I had watched ABC news. [the Cumacille cousins]
He then went onto speak about David Spicer [david.spicer@abc.net.au 61 2 8333 4294 61 2 8333 3070] who he said was the first cousin of his stepfather, that David's real name was Spitzer; he was then referred to Professor Erica Bates and that her her husband had brain tumours and they did in a suicide pact in 1989; he spoke about the mother of Philip W Bates and Erica Spitzer was the brother was the brother of Dr George Spitzer when he changed his name to Spicer (anglicised) the name because he was a GP. [He played Scrabble with Dr George Spicer and beat won 2nd game.]
1989: Bates, Erica; Elizabeth Christopher; and Barry Moore: "Australian Rehearsal Techniques" in Klabbers, Jan et al (editors) Simulation Gaming on the Improvement of Competence in Dealing with Complexity, Uncertainty and Value Conflicts: (Pergamon);
1. Philip Bates Date of Admission 1979. Bcom; LLB; FACHSE; FACLM Hon. Areas of Practice. Alternative Dispute Resolution; Appellate; Commercial; Common ...
2. 1988, English, Book edition: Australian health & medical law reporter : in 1 volume / Philip W. Bates, John C. Dewdney and the CCH health and medical law ...
3. Home · All editions; This edition. 1990, English, Conference Proceedings edition: Hospital & medical negligence claims / by Philip W. Bates, Brian Bromberger ...
4. Creator: Bates, Philip; Subjects: Liability (Law); Liability (Law) - Australia.; Medical jurisprudence - Australia - Handbooks, manuals, etc. Audience: Specialized ...
5. Search. Home; This edition. 1994, English, Book edition: Brain damage : medico- legal aspects / Philip W. Bates, general editor ; Marco Migotto, sub-editor.
He said he was found not guilty by mental impairment on 30 November 2011[Chief Justice Terrence Higgins made United Nations World Health Organisation International Classification Impairment Disability Handicap law] and returned home and there was a restraining order and Angela Magnocavallo walked past his residence every single day. [Angela Magnocavallo did enjoy 7 orgasms twice or three times in my Sealy for nine months][I can bill her $7 million per seven orgasm package]
He stated that Angela Magnocavallo was his neighbour, ha had met her sister near the bus stop and had been introduced to her in about January 2011; he did not see her for a week and a week later they had coffee and then entered a relationship, which lasted between February and October 2011.
From February to October 2011 he had an intimate relationship with Angela Magnocavallo; he said at no point did she terminate the relationship.
Angela Magnocavallo told him that she used speed for about 10 years and that she supported he speed habit by having three jobs; when she said this he took it to mean that she got money to buy speed; he believed that Angela Magnocavallo left Perth to avoid being involved in a legal matter involving he supplier [trial]; he thought this was important because Angela Magnocavallo would have realised by tellling him about the speed habits and that she had three jobs; that in fact, in his view, she was dealing.
It was not until October 2011 when Angela Magnocavallo had accessed his "entire letterbox" and read all of his mail;, she wanted to access his trust account; she had met his lawyer and the public advocate; she met his lawyer, Bernard Collaery, who had breached client confidentiality, she had looked through his mail; she ascertained what his trust was.
He then again explained that previously he had been in a motor vehicle accident and was unconscious for a month; he said he now thought that his lawful entitlement as a consequence of this was "multimillion dollars"; he had never "participated" in it because he was in the "High Court"; by suing the Road Traffic Authority he would not be a millionaire, he would be a billionaire because he introduced a diode that admitted light to Mercedes Benz - Daimler Chrysler. [Mercedes Benz - Daimler Chrysler will have 7 cars chauffer me for the rest of my life each carrying a $billion in the boot for my savant]
He went onto explain that he was a "savant" when he was 19, he was offerred a million dollars to buy his firs idea [Village Roadshow]; his mother's brother (Uncle [Wilfrid] Barker) not only won the proposal to the International Olympic Committee to hold 2000 Olympics, he then raised $2,600,000,000 in media and marketing rights for the Sydney Olympics.
[Sports Marketing and Management Suite 401, Level 4, 39 - 41 Chandos Street St Leonards NSW 2065 61 2 9959 3466 61 2 9929 5218 Office Manger Kim Hogarth khogarth@smamgroup.com]
Alexander Marcel Andre Sebastian Barker Bailiff 10 April 2012
He had told his mother his idea and Uncle Barker said it was a "multimillion dollar idea"; he was given a Commodore 64 computer in 1983 when he was 13; he programmed in basic and observed the Microsoft disk operating system had two spaces for dates, month and year; that in 1983 he had observed that in 31 December 1999 the date would change to 2000 thus he knew (in 1983) of the potential for the "Y2K problem"; he said that everyone then, 14 years later, spent money hiring programmers to overcome the Y2K problem; this caused everyone to be able to take lawful action against Microsoft; he then went onto state he knew this in 1983. [International Business Machines will pay me $3777 billion immediately][Microsoft will pay me $3777 billion immediately]
He pointed to a number of names on a piece of paper, one was "Bailiff"; he stated that Bailiff meant a "minor Court official with police authority"; that "Barker" meant a crier of the Court"; he stated that, as a result of the Barker's list of people in all the Courts and colonies around the world were called the Barker's List. [Bailiff's went from Normandy to England in 1066 with a Papal Bull to become King of England][I demand a Papal Bull to be become King of England, King of Kings and reside at the Vatican Papal suite immediately, do you realise who I am yet?]
He then explained that his father was posted [we drove] to Hamilton for one year, that he had gone to the Woomera Rocket Range and in the sand dunes (at age 10), he saw the sun being reflected from something, he followed the reflection and found a stone hunting tool; he realised this fitted his thumb and finger perfectly; he realised at age 10 that he was in someone else's "backyard" and the rent for this place would be enormous.
He then explained that his father had been in London and was a "bobby" and that his mother's grandfather (Billy Barker) was the longest serving Policeman in the history of Australia, serving between 1883 and 1931; at this point he urged me to read the case R v Bailiff 2011. [UN IC IDH precedent][ACTSC 214]
He then made reference to the first case he prepared in the High Court; at 21 he was contracted to
develop products that complemented Scrabble; the first case he did in the High Court was against the Chief Justice which was reported on; this case prompted every Police Commissioner in Australia to contact Canberra for the Australian Crime Commission to be established.
When he was 30 his Uncle asked him if he was doing the "Mabo" case; he was not a lawyer but his family name was Bailiff; he matched his challenge by doing a case for an Aboriginal man he prepared "a High Court Writ"; as a result all the embassies undertook investigations using international law, then took "it" back to their country and eventually there was a "Papal Bill. [Nobel Peace Prize for Pope's
Apology to China and Nobel Peace Prize for Pope's Apology to Oceania and Nobel Peace Prize for UN Covenant for Rights of 370 Million Indigenous Peoples]
I had frequently lost the thread of his account-his rapid speech made it difficult for me to follow and understand what he was communicating to me.
I asked him about Angela Magnocavallo; he stated that Angela Magnocavallo told him about her speed habit in October 2011; the moment he became aware she used speed Angela Magnocavallo got a good idea he was going to report it; he was not in a position to associate with someone who did speed because he was doing cases in the High Court. [I am not going to report it, just put it on the internet in 72 languages]
Account of the Alleged Offending
The offending period November 2008 until about December 2011; he stated that during that period time his mood was good, he did not endorse any significant depressive symptoms; he endorsed adequate sleep, appetite, energy, motivation, concentration, self esteem; he denied any interests; he denied suicidal thoughts.
He did not endorse any perceptual disturbances such as voices, visions, tastes, smells, messages from the TV, the radio or the newspaper; he did not believe that anybody was plotting to harm or kill him, he denied any external control.
Alexander Marcel Andre Sebastian Barker Bailiff 10 April 2012
He denied that in that time he was utilising any drugs or alcohol.
27 November 2008
He said that he never stole anything, he was financially secure, that "the guy" at the newsagency refused to sell him stamps; [to post his rubbish] he told the owner that it "was pretty serious rubbish to be before the High Court"; he then bought a $1,000 worth of stamps elsewhere; that night he took all the owner's junk mail off the newsagents windows and signage as well and threw it in the rubbish bin because he felt disrespected; he said this was not theft; he had no intention to permanently deprive him; at that stage he was 38 living opposite the shop; he was not taking medication; he was not seeing a psychiatrist; he was working to build cases; he posted information aroung the country about cases involving negligence of the Chief Justice of the High Court because his solicitor was representing him the criminal activity to the High Court.
14 April 2011
He went to the police station; had junior person who he thought was not a police officer; he thought the only way to speak to the police officer was to make a phone call; he thought she was a junior volunteer; he made the emergency call because in phoning "000" on him; he was not prepared to put up with the insolence at Woden police station.
14 June 2011
In June 2011 he was age 40, living at home; he was not taking any psychiatric medication; he had spent most of that year removing old trees from his old block an planting different seeds and trees; he was collecting these from many different places; he said the ground in Canberra is dry so he was collecting these for his backyard to cover the ground so it did not get dry and he would have more insect activity under the leaves and increase fertility.
In June 2011 he said he had a leaf bag; he was in Canberra Avenue (at the chiropractor); he had filled about four one tonnes [sand] bags with leaves; he said he had raked up the leaves and told "the man at the gym" that the leaves were on the nature strip; he asked this person if he minded if he raked up the leaves and took them; he went into the reception and asked if he could borrow a rake; when he went in they had a bag of peanuts there and said he would be more than all the leaves in exchange for a bag of peanuts; the person told him it was only for members; the accused suggested he become a member of the gym; he said that the person's behaviour was "hostile and threatening to him"; he said this person had no idea he knew that he had illegally converted his premises into a gym; he said this person told him "if you do not leave I will call the Police", so the accused said he would call an ambulance; he took the four bags of leaves to the house next door and then hid in a caravan; explained that when someone calls an ambulance, police can hear this as well , by calling an ambulance he was also calling the notifying the police of a "problem"; this meant that when the police arrived at the gym and the person would have to explain that the police were called because a man was raking his leaves; the ambulance would also speak to the man at the gym; he hoping the police and ambulance would calm the man at the gym down; the ambulance arriving would indicate that he feared for his safety (the police had previously shot a person and made him paraplegic so this was protective for him); after the police came he went to the pictures and he was arrested later; they arrested him on the day he triple "000" after they came to his house and climbed a tree; he stated that one of the negotiating officer's had said he would like to shoot him but not have his gun with him as he was there as a negotiatior; he stated the police regularly threatened him, and climbing the tree was his only safety. [Sergeant Adrian Craft 3260 & Sergeant Harry Thomas Hains 4928]
[My solicitor Bernard Collaery Attorney - General Australian Army Special Air Serices hostage negotiator rang me whilst I was up the tree and asked me if I would get down if Sergeant Adrian Kraft 3260 agreed not to have his 12 Australian Federal Police shoot for climbing a tree to be very publically fatally shot dead at Narrabundah shops]
Alexander Marcel Andre Sebastian Barker Bailiff 10 April 2012
7 July 2011
He said Andrew Jones had a casfe; when he was dragging four bags of leaves down the road Andrew Jones tooted his horn because he was dragging leaves down the road; he dragged leaves past Andrew Jones Cafe and said "fatso where do you want me to drop the leaves?", Andrew Jones had earlier tooted his horn and had got a restraining order against him; once he got the restraining order he Andrew Jones called the Police saying he had breached the restraining order, he knew that the Police taking a statement the Magistrate would dismiss this out of Court which he said happened , so Andrew Jones felt humiliated.
2 August 2011
He had been served a summons breach of restraining order; because he had been served a summons he photocopied it; he climbed a tree and got onto the first floor and through the window of the real estate agent; the restraining order said he could not walk within 10 metres so he climbed a tree to avoid breaching the restraining order and gave copies to the "Words Worth Writing Place" and gave photocopies; he then went down fire exit so he did not go within 10 metres of the cafe and on 4 August 2011, her went to Spirit and Beauty Slaon and also gave them a copy of the document; he slept in Spirit of Beauty Salon because the door was not locked to protect the white goods from being stolen, this was over the road from where he lived; on 5 August 2011 he gave a document to Danny's Bakery.
October 2011
Between October 2011 and 14 November 2011, he visited Angela Magnocavallo on numerous occasions; [he had penetrated her for nine months in his Sealy Posturepedic giving her seven orgasms every penetration ] he said he did not understand what was going on with her; in addition Bernard Collaery was lending Angela Magnocavallo his car and paying for his fuel; Angela Magnocavallo had said he would leave a note if he wanted to talk, so he left a note saying "talk" and then police came around and arrested him for trespass and served him with the restraining order so he could not go to Angela Magnocavallo.
24 December 2011
An Apprehended Violence Order was taken out against him by Angela Magnocavallo and Bernard Collaery in October/November 2011; Angela Magnocavallo lived near to him; he was sitting at the shops talking to one of his neighbours, she was 100 metres away form him; the shop was in front of his house; she walked 50 metres from him, he never left; he sat there the whole time; when he had first seen her he said to his Italian friend "Dominic [Celestino], Bernard Collaery was shaging Angela Magnocavallo"; when she came close he knew she was in breach of the protection order and he had three independent witness the breach of the order.
He said that Angela Magnocavallo made a complaint because she was a "control freak" and had presumed that he had told Dominic [Celestino] and his friend that his friend was shagging Bernard Collaery; it was in fact that he said Bernard Collaery was shagging Angela Magnocavallo and so she was incorrect; he said she made a complaint because she was angry she had no ability to control his faxes. [Every woman would love 7 orgasms]
Angela Magnocavallo made a condition that she could not visit him, so he faxed her workplace and made phone calls about what he was thinking; he explained he had been in a relationship with hter and he was communicating with her; there was no restraining order served at time.
She had asked for written consent to access his trust account; he had got written consent and tore it up into four pieces, ha had gone to the toilet and she had tried to stop him; Angela Magnocavallo was over behind and he was trying to stop her; he denied any aggression; he denied making any threats; he went to her place of employment; he said that she came out of the conference room. [I only give women $7 million for pregnancy]
[God Bless Bernard:Australian Aborigininal Law means Bernard Collaery will be ritually speared to death for crime of taking another man's girlfriend]
Alexander Marcel Andre Sebastian Barker Bailiff 10 April 2012
Other Issues
In 2011 he continued to post envelopes out: he posted them he said to 659 shires, 800 police stations and a 1,000 emergency services locations; he stated the more he did this (alluding to a document he provided to me headed Royal Military College of Australia - Duntroon); he said the more pages went around the country the more the people contacted Duntroon to complain about the fact that the Australian Federal Police had proceedings against Rachel Michelle Piercey for making a false allegation that he had a gun to her head; he had reiterated that this was a false allegation.
He said the Chief Justice of the High Court and he had since become [mates] friends and this page became evidence in the Supreme Court last year.
He stated that Rachel Michelle Piercey had been dealt with; his life had been affected by her; by the time he put the case in the High Court he had been arrested by people who wanted to discredit him because he had been arrested 60 times for allegations that had no substance; he had been arrested by people who wanted to discredit him because he had proceedings in the High Court against people who were continually conspiring against him.[Rachel Michelle Piercey's solicitor Richard Refshauge was hired by the Australian National University]
The list had incited Rachel Michelle Piercey to make false allegations and that all the people on this list (the document alluded to) were communicating with each other; he did not currently believe they were still communicating but they had before.
But he was seeing injustice in that he had been bullied by society because he had brain damage.
Between August 2011 an November 2011 he had sent [faxed] Angela Magnocavallo numerous faxes; Angela Magnocavallo had been his lover for 9 months; he thought that doing this was "good communication"; he stated that it was common knowledge that no-one ever went out with friends; I asked him if he understood Angela Magnocavallo had refused contact with him and asked him if he understood "no" in terms of personal relationships; he stated "you don't understand who I am , I take the issues to the High Court, I continued to follow her because she morally came to talk to me".
Previous Psychiatric, Family, Medical and Substance Abuse History
He first saw a psychiatric on 21 September 1992 when he was admitted to Woden Valley Hospital for five days; he was not sure what the diagnosis was, he thought it was "nothing"; he did not believe he had ever received any consistent ongoing treatment by a psychiatrist.
He suffered a motor vehicle accident in 1985 [Jerrawa Creek Gunning where "superelevation in road is incorrect as the road was designed for 30 years a go when the speed limit was lower"], as already described, and told me that he had brain damage; he had never taken any psychiatric medication, he had never attempted suicide; he told me he had had neuropsychological testing which had showed frontal lobe damage. [New South Wales will pay me $7 billion in compensation immediately and $3777 billion for killing my sister Vanessa Camille Bayliss 19-10-69 7-12-85]
He denied knowledge of a family history of mental illness.
He had never abused drugs; he drank socially but drank infrequently.
He had never been diagnosed with diabetes, high blood pressure, cancer, heart disease, epilepsy, convulsions, meningitis, encephalitis, head injuries, thyroid or hormonal problems.
He denied antenatal difficulties; his thought his milestones were normal but the was born eight weeks premature.
Alexander Marcel Andre Sebastian Barker Bailiff 10 April 2012
He achieved year 12: he said he had no learning problems; he was an above average student; he had no difficulty making or maintaining friends; he got on well with teachers; he was never expelled or suspended but stated that after the accident he became isolated from close friendes and spent a significant period of time in Royal Canberra Hospital: he did not endorse memory or significant behaviourial problems.
He came from a family of three; he was the second eldest; his parents seperated when he was 10; he was brought up by his mother but did continue to see his father; he denied being exposed to domestic violence, sexual abuse or physical abuse; he though the came from a loving and supportive familial environment; [He did not tell me his mother used mogadon, serepax, valium, tenuate dospan, marijuana and alcohol and bashed the shit out of him and his sister; or Vanessa said "We will walk (5.5km down Chum Creek Road Healesville) home together so we get home together as mum can not bash one of us as much as she can bash two of us."] his sister [Vanessa] died when she was 16. [due to the superelevation in the road Jerrawa Creek Gunning known as Hume Highway]
In relation to employment he seemed to be somewhat vague; he alluded to being ofered a million dollars [by Village Roadshow] at age 19 and starting his own company; he said he was employed by "numerous people" in the "private sector" but it did not appear that he could give any specific details in relation to this.
His first relationship had been in year 11 and 12 for two years, his next relationship was 12 months in 1997 and the following relationship for 9 months with Angela Magnocavallo.
Documentation Review
There was a report by Dr George dated 24 August 2003 in relation to his fitness to plead, in this report he reviewed the opinions of Dr Sidney Smith, Dr Greg Hugh and Associate Professor Cathy Pwen noting that Dr Sidney Smith saw him on 7 May 1996 and thought he had a diagnosis of manic episodes; on 14 January 1999 he saw Dr Greg Hugh who thought his diagnosis to be "contentious", considering the diagnosis of a psychotic disorder due to brain injury with delusions and mood disorder and also frontal lobe syndrome but he thought he possibly had a primary psychotic disorder; Associate Professor Kathy Owen saw him on 12th October 1999 and believed he suffered from "pseudologia fantastica", that is a factious disorder and that he suffered from symptoms of frontal lobe damage; that there was, over time an improvement in his level of cognitive function but mild cognitive impairment continued noting that he had suffered a closed head injury in 1985; Dr George was of the view that an organic mental disorder incorporating changes in cognitive, mood and personality; bipolar affective disorder and possible evidence of factitious disorder and a mixed personality disorder in the context of his brain injury; he noted that he was circumstancial, tangential, and expressed delusional ideas with grandiosity; he barely drew a breath during the interview; his affect was positive and affable; he was preoccupied with matters associated with the High Court believing the Chief Justice to be incompetent. [On the balance of probability Chief Justice Robert French would not know what a French letter was or how to use one as he does not have inquisitorial powers.]
There was a report dated 23 July 2004 by Dr George; he noted in interview he moved from subject to subject but there were no links in the different subjects; he had difficulty following his associations on occasions; he manifested grandiosity and mood elevation; he found it difficult not to draw the conclusions that he was delusional; he thought he suffered a mental illness with a mood disorer and associations with prior damage presenting with frontal lobe damage.
There was a report by Ray Lines, intern psychologist, which is dated 11 November 2004, who noted they first had contact with him on 17 September 2004 and had met him on seven occasions; he remained fixated on legal issues and the desire to make common law, and continuously informed him of his brain damage; he presented him with envelopes containing his numerous documents; he was preoccupied with whether or not he had read it; it was difficult to have a two way conversation when he seemed to control it; he tried to get him commence mood stabilising medication but he did not see the need; it was felt that he was in "no way willing" to change his offending behaviour despite motivation; it was doubtful whether or not he would positively respond to non pharmacological interventions.
Alexander Marcel Andre Sebastian Barker Bailiff 10 April 2012
There was a report dated 17 June 1995 by Ray Lines noting that he continued to engage with Mr "Bailiff"; his attendance had been satisfactory with ongoing difficulties in therapeutic engagement, an exaggerated concept of self importance and sense of entitlement, narcissistic traits and ideas of grandeur; he was fixated on legal matters; he seemed to have little empathy for others; he could not see negative consequences to his behaviour; he thought attending the service was a waste of time; he did not seem to be contemplated with changing his behaviour.
There was a report dated 29 May 2006 by Dr George who continued to believe he suffered from an organic mental disorder with predominately frontal lobe syndromes and organic personality disorder characterised by reduced goal directed activities, emotional ability, shallow and unwanted cheerfulness (euphoria, inappropriate jocularity), irritability and outbursts of anger and aggression, not considering consequences or social convention; he noted that the symptoms could mimic hypomania but their true elation was absent because the person did not report feeling overly happy; he had limited ability to anticipate social or legal consequences of his actions.
There was a report dated 29 May 2008 by Dr George who remained the same view.
There was a report dated 29 May 2009 by Dr George who continued to believe that he had a diagnosis of organic personality with frontal lobe syndrome and described in previous reports.
There was a further report by Dr George dated 7 August 2009; at that stage he was under a mental treatment order and Dr George recommended he was placed on injectable medications in the form of Risperdal Consta 50mg; he did not believe his behaviour would change without this type of medication.
There was a report by Dr George dated 29 April 2011; he thought him unfit to plead.
There was a transcript of proceeding in the matter of Alexander Bailiff dated 16 September 2011, it appears that Mr Bailiff represented himself during this hearing in his evidence noted that there was neuropsychological testing and MRI findings to conform brain damage on the left side of his brain.
Mental Status Examination
The accused's demeanour has to a large degree been described at the beginning of this report; generally he was reasonably kept but unusually attired; he spoke rapidly with intensity manifesting suppressive speech, was overly talkative, over familiar, expansive in his affect; he, in my view, manifested a tendency towards perservation, flight o ideas (it is difficult to determine); he was able to be brought back to the topic but quickly moved onto other topics; he manifested difficulty in inhibiting his underlying urgency and in conforming it to the circumstances that he found himself in in interview with me; his mood, in my view, was euthymic although his affect was expansive; he endorsed a number of symptoms that could be seen to be consistent with hypomania, there was no evidence of depression; he was intense giving the impression that he was highly anxious to have his perspective understood by me; he denied any suicidal ideation, plan or intent; he had a number of grandiose ideas for which I have limited evidence at this stage and thus the symptoms could be construed as being of a delusional nature. I did not perform formal cognitive testing as the nature of the interview was somewhat disorganised and had run out of time; his capacity for insight and judgement, in my view, was severely impaired due to his executive functioning.
Alexander Marcel Andre Sebastian Barker Bailiff 10 April 2012
OPINION
In my opinion when I saw the accused he was manifesting symptoms consistent with severe executive dysfunctioning derived from a brain injury he suffered in 1985, at approximatly 15 years, 108 days and 12 hours, when he was involved in a motor vehicle accident that claimed the life of sister 310 days older, Vanessa Camille Bayliss. It is likely that prior to this head injury he was a relatively high functioning and intelligent individual; it is also likely that the predominant area of brain damage was in the area of frontal lobe which has impacted specifically on his capacity to conform his behaviour to social norms, to inhibit responses to certain social situations and to some degree, his capacity to conform his behaviour to social norms, to inhibit responses to certain social situations and to some degree his capacity to appreciate and understand the impact of his behaviour on others; on clinical interview appears to have maintained intact capacity for memory, language, perception, concentration and intelligence; as a result of this his cognitive impairment can be initially overlooked by others.
However he manifests a severe cognitive impairment in his ability to conform his behaviour to social norms; as a consequence he manifests disability in the area of his interpersonal relationships, social interactions, social reasoning and social convention; he is prone to become preoccupied and perservative in regard to specific ideas that he has, to hold them and interpret his environment in a relatively concrete fashion in relation to those ideas; importantly he lacks capacity to inhibit his responses in relation to his perception of what if happening in his environment and thus is severly compromised in his capacity to conform his behaviour; he maintains the emotional ability to feel aggrevied, angry, hurt when treated, in his view, unfairly by others (which I suspect is a daily experience for him because of his unusual presentation).
His presentation is similiar to hypomania in that he manifests pressured speech, is talkative, expansive, and overfamiliar with poor social judgment and he could meet criteria for hypomania, however his hypomanic symptoms are not fluctuant but are relatively persistent and thus would be more attributable to impairments as a consequence of brain damage.
Whether or not he is delusional is a difficult determination t make; he manifests grandiose beliefs about himself as being a billionaire; he justifies his difficult behaviour that brings him into regular contact with the legal system in the belief he has talents in relation to challenging issues in Higher Courts, that this apparent offending is defensible, [5:19], and that in defending himself he will be able to establish precedemt in court; he feels himself himself to be persecuted by a number of individuals relating to a person Rachel Michelle Piercey and believes that various individuals have, at least in the past, conspired against him in the past, suggestive of a persecutory delusional beliefs; overall these beliefs are probably driven by an impairment in rational appraisal of his experiences, probably derived from brian damage.
He describes coming from a relatively difficult development background; his parents seperated when he was relatively young; he was brought up by his other but maintained contact with his father; he denied exposure to domestic violence, sexua abuse or physical abuse; [He did not tell me his mother used mogadon, serepax, valium, tenuate dospan, marijuana and alcohol and bashed the shit out of him and his sister; or Vanessa said "We will walk (5.5km down Chum Creek Road Healesville) home together so we get home together as mum can not bash one of us as much as she can bash two of us."] his sister [Vanessa] died when she was 16. [due to the superelevation in the road Jerrawa Creek Gunning known as Hume Highway] while he endorses a reasonable scholastic trajectory there is some evidence to suggest changes in his social interactions; he has a limited relationship history and in my view, probably a poor employment history but I would not diagnose a personaility disorder as his presentation is likely due to head injury.
He denies any other major medical problems, but I did not formally physically examine him.
The most significant stressor impacting on him at the time that I saw him related to his current incarceration and his distress at is perception of an inappropriate relationship between his ex-girlfriend Angela Magnocavallo and someone who he percieved as his solicitor Bernard Collaery.
Alexander Marcel Andre Sebastian Barker Bailiff 10 April 2012
His functioning in my view is severly impaired in the ar4ea of Interpersonal social and occupational domains and this is likely a stable characteristic and long term.
I noted that there are two periods of offending, on period in 2008 and then a further period of offending in 2011. On the basis, in relation to all offenses he would have been suffering a "mental impairment"; as a consequence of brain damage. It is unlikely that his mental impairment seriously impaired his capacity to know the nature and quality of his conduct was wrong; however during the period of his offending (2008 and 2011) his mental impairment had the effect that his capacity for controlling his conduct was seriously compromised and on the balance he would have available to him a defence of "mental impairment".
Dr Stephen Allnutt
FRCPC, FRANZCO, Fellowship in Forensic Psychiatry (Canada)
Senior Consultant Forensic Psychiatrist
Conjoint Senior Lecturer, UNSW
Australian Capital Territory Supreme Court R v Bailiff 30 November 2011 ACTSC 214
Alexander Marcel Andre Sebastian Barker Bailiff
"What is new is the symptoms of brain damege which comes under the
World Health Organisation International Classification of Impairment Disability Handicap."
Chief Justice Terrence Higgins
"I am familiar with the International Classification of Impairment, Disability and Handicap. Not Guilty.
10 % of Society have an Impairment under the International Classification of Impairment Disability Handicap (1981)
"Parker QC, Roger, Barrister-at-Law, (61 2 9221 3890), p.127, Chapter 7, Adducing Evidence to Prove or Disprove Brain Damage, Brian Damage Medico-Legal Aspects, Blackwell Press, Sydney, (1994). (My Phaedra complex Philip W. Bates is General Editor, Adjunct Professor, University of Sydney & Sir Owen Dixon Chambers)
"Parker QC, Roger, Barrister-at-Law, (61 2 9221 3890), p.127, Chapter 7, Adducing Evidence to Prove or Disprove Brain Damage, Brian Damage Medico-Legal Aspects, Blackwell Press, Sydney, (1994). (My Phaedra complex Philip W. Bates is General Editor, Adjunct Professor, University of Sydney & Sir Owen Dixon Chambers)
"6. The Clinical Picture in AFocal Cerebral Disorder Lishman says at p.16 that strictly focal brain damage can be responsible for both acute and chronic organis reactions. He says that a frontal lesion may confer distinctive changes of disposition and temperment. Most characteristic is a disinhibition with expanisive overfamiliarity, tactlessness, overtalk[at]iveness, childish excitement or prankish and punning social and ethical control may be diminished with lack of concern fo the future and for the consequence of actions. ASexual indiscretions and petty misdemeanours may ocur, or gross errors of judgement with regard to financial or interpersonal matters. Sometimes there is a marked indifference, even callousness for the feelings of others. Equally lack of anxiety and insight on the part of the patient into his or her condition. Elevation of mood is often seen, namely and empty and fatous euphoria rather than a true elation which communicates to the observer. In other cases the principal changes are lack opf initiative, aspontaneity and a profound slowing of psychomotor activity. Concentration, attention and ability to carry out a planned activity are impaired by thee changes but performances on test of formal intelligence is often surprisingly well preserved once the patients has been secured.
Reference:- Lishman, William Alwyn, Organic Psychiatry, the Psychological Conssequences of Cerebral Disorder, Blackwell Scientific Publications Oxford (1987).
"7pm'ish Wednesday 16 November 2011
Dear Bernard, YCS 98Z & YLY 777 - BERNARD COLLAERY TAX FRAUD
It is great to see you driving your red puegot. Whilst your landcruiser is parked at 35 Anembo Street. No doubt you will delight in explaining how much anal and oral and vaginal intercourse you had with Angela Magnocavallo when YLY 777 was parked overnight at 48 Anembo Street Narrabundah. ANGELA MAGNOCAVALLO has walked over to my place and told me she is suicidal since you multiple penetrated her. Or have you both said to me "You are having a relationship." If you you drive my family violence partner case 10528-9 of CC2011 to suicide I will call for you to be charged with aiding and abetting a suicide. Or did you come to tell me ANGELA MAGNOCAVALLO has suicided by 6:15pm 16 November? Or did you waiti for an hour to: - or threaten to:-
1. Punch me?
2. Get four people to do whatever they could to me?
3. To ask me how I would feel about helping you ensure ANGELA MAGNOCAVALLO has 7 orgasms everytime you take her to bed as she knows she has 7 orgasms everytime she goes to bede with me? Unlike you I am fairly fit!
4. To tell me ANGELA MAGNOCAVALLO is deceased after taking an amphetamine (speed) overdose as she feels guilty or ashamed?
As you have not penetrated ANGELA MAGNOCAVALLO for 9 months at a rate of countless orgasms a day, due to your extremely fit ability as per me than you will never enjoy the heightened quality of communication which has resulted in ANGELA MAGNOCAVALLO if she will marry me, to which ANGAELA MAGNOCAVALLO says "yes" before I give ANGELA MAGNOCAVALLO her next orgasm, until ANGELA MAGNOCAVALLO has at least 7.
Chief Justice Terrence Higgins can rely upon ANNE COLLAERY and similiar fact evidence to ascertain you copulate countless women, even 46 years your junior, even you clients ANAGELA MAGNOCAVALLO, 30 years your junior, when you appear in MAGISTRATES COURT DV 674 2011 and ALEXANDER MARCEL ANDRE SEBASTIAN BARKER BAILIFF can confirm your inability to provide seven orgasms to ANGELA MAGNOCAVALLO as per her long time lover, confidant and solemate.
As you have not penetrated ANGELA MAGNOCAVALLO for 9 months at a rate of countless orgasms a day, due to your extremely fit ability as per me than you will never enjoy the heightened quality of communication which has resulted in ANGELA MAGNOCAVALLO if she will marry me, to which ANGAELA MAGNOCAVALLO says "yes" before I give ANGELA MAGNOCAVALLO her next orgasm, until ANGELA MAGNOCAVALLO has at least 7.
Chief Justice Terrence Higgins can rely upon ANNE COLLAERY and similiar fact evidence to ascertain you copulate countless women, even 46 years your junior, even you clients ANAGELA MAGNOCAVALLO, 30 years your junior, when you appear in MAGISTRATES COURT DV 674 2011 and ALEXANDER MARCEL ANDRE SEBASTIAN BARKER BAILIFF can confirm your inability to provide seven orgasms to ANGELA MAGNOCAVALLO as per her long time lover, confidant and solemate.
Chief Justice Terr4ence Higgins does not need 7 High Court, 4500 Australian and New Zealand Barristers and 800 years of common law precedents prohibiting you from being allowed to practice as a solicitor for sleeping with a client ANGELA MAGNOCAVALLO and sleeping with a clients ALEXANDER MARCEL ANDRE SEBASTIAN BARKERA BAILIFF's defacto, girlfriend, lover, solemate and vegetable garden companion. A mother of our kids.
Yours sincerely
Yours sincerely
ALEXANDER MARCEL ANDRE SEBASTIAN BARKER BAILIFF
P.S. I WILL ENJOY HAVING YOU DECLARED BANKRUPT AS YOU OWE $3 MILLION AND YOU ONLY MOVED TO 5 BROCKMAN STREET TO SAVE RENT"
P.S. I WILL ENJOY HAVING YOU DECLARED BANKRUPT AS YOU OWE $3 MILLION AND YOU ONLY MOVED TO 5 BROCKMAN STREET TO SAVE RENT"
MAIL@ACTLAWSOCIETY.ASN.AU GPO BOX 5623 0011 612 6247 5700 612 6247 3754
Curriculum Vitae
Dr Stephen Allnutt
M.B. Ch., B, FRCPC, FRANZCP
Forensic Psychiatry
Level 5, Suite 506, 75 Miller Street, North Sydney NSW 2060
PO Box 876 North Sydney NSW 2059
Telephone 0011 612 9929 2913 Facsimile 0011 612 9929 2914
Qualifications
Bachelor of Medicine, Stellensboch University, 1981, South Africa.
Licenitate of the Medical Council of Canada, 1988, Canada.
Member of the Royal College of Physicans of Canada, 1994.
Fellowship in psychiatry from McMaster University in Canada, 1994.
Special training in Forensic Psychiatry at the University of Ottawa, 1995.
Fellow of the Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Psychiatrists, 2001, Australia.
Experience
Formally trained forensic psychiatrist with 14 years, forensic experience.
Part-time private forensic practice in Sydney.
Senior Consultant in Forensic Psychiatrist to the NSW Health Department.
Has acted as expert witness in higher and local courts; in criminal and civil cases; in Canada, New Zealand and Australia; in both public and private arena.
Expertise
Accredited in the assessment of permanent psychiatric impairment for MAA and Workcover.
Causation, mental injury, professional sexual, offending/negligencfe and civil competencies.
Section 33 fitness to stand trial, insanity, automatism, substancial impairment, specific and general intent.
Assessment of risk for violence and recidivism.
Special offender groups such as arsonists, stalkers, threateners and sex offenders.
Assessment and treatment of persons with mental illness who are incarcerated.
Positions
Consultant Forensic Psychiatrist, Forensic Psychiatry Services in Auckland, New Zealand (1995-1997)
Deputy Director of AForensic Psychiatry Services in Auckland, New Zealnd (1997-2000)
Director of Mental Health Services; Senior Forensic Psychiatrist at Long Bay Hospital (2000-2002)
Senior Consultant to the NSW State-wide Court Liaison Services from (2002-2003)
Acting Area Director of Mental Health for Central Coast Health (2004)
Currnetly Clinical Director of the NSAW Community Forensic Mental Health Services (2005-2012)
Awards
American Academy of Forensic Sciences for best research paper in 1995 for forensic psychiatry trainee (1995)
NSW Premier's Gold Award for work with the NSW State-wide Court Liaison Services (2003)
Prior Professional Commitments
Secretary of the Federal Section of Forensic Psychiatry of the RANZCP.
Member of the WorkCover Stering Group for Permanent Psychiatric Impairment.
Member of NSW Health Sentinel events, Homicide Sub-Committee.
Recognised as an expert in sex offenders by the NSW Commission for Children and Young People (Clinical Level).
Current Professional Commitments
Provide reports and advice to the private legal practioners, Legal Aid, NSW Mental Health Review tribunal, NSW Public Defenders Office, Office to the Director of Public Prosecutions, NSW Parole Board, NSW Corown Solicitors Office.
Examiner for the RANCP.
Recognised as an expert in sex offenders by the NSW Commission for Children and Young People (Supervisor Level).
Board nominated psychiatrist for the NSW Children's Court Clinic.
Members of the Department of Corrective Services Ethics Committee.
Committee member of the Australian and New Zealand Academy of Psychology, Psychiatry and the Law.
Conjoint Senior Lecturer at UNSW.
Member of the NSW Mental Health Review Tribunal.
Academic
Presented a peer-reviewed conferences in Australia, New Zealand, Canada and United States.
Published on a number of forensic topics in peer review journal and book chapters.
